Why I Chose Homeschooling After O Levels
In 2020, when I finished my O levels, it was time to choose an A level college. By then, I had already been exposed to books, lectures, and ideas about homeschooling. I had also learned how children are exploited, rebuked, punished, tested, controlled, and humiliated in schools.
None of that had happened to me, since I was a high achiever. But, cherry on top, high achievers often go through an even more disturbed psychological state than low achievers.
With scholarships pouring in from the top colleges of the city, I had to choose.
I knew my character and confidence had been deeply affected by the schooling system. For a high achiever, failure feels like the end of the world, even a small failure. A-graders are afraid of mistakes, and they learn only for exams. They also hate it when the limelight changes direction. I could not repeat the same mistake. Knowing something and not putting it into practice would have been a deception.
My choice was made: homeschooling.
It was a difficult decision, but a fruitful one, and fruitful enough to urge me to write this.
What Is Homeschooling?
As the name suggests, homeschooling means studying at home. Instead of joining a formal institution like a school or college, students study through books and, if needed, external help such as tuitions or coaching.
Why Homeschooling Is a Better Option Than School
1. It saves a huge amount of time
Schools take away a learner’s most precious resource: time. In his book Dumbing Us Down, teacher John Taylor Gatto works out how much free time the children he teaches actually have. Out of 168 hours in a week, he counts about 56 for sleep and 55 for television. Schooling itself, with getting ready and homework, takes roughly 45 more. After meals, only about 9 hours a week remain for private time.
That is the most basic problem. How will children find time to play a sport? How will a Muslim child find time for pondering and reflection when none is left?
Even if we assume that sending children to school is a worthwhile use of time and resources, schools often fail at teaching, and much of what they impart is unnecessary and out of context. In Punished by Rewards, Alfie Kohn argues that a good deal of what students are required to do in school is not worth doing. One day a child learns Newton’s laws, and the next day the calibration of a thermometer. One piece of information has yet to make sense when another is thrown at them. Students face a jumble of facts, none of which settles clearly.
Homeschooling saves all that crucial time and makes room for a more meaningful learning experience.
2. It allows more natural interaction
Homeschooled children spend time learning with friends, immediate and extended family, and on the greater goals of life, unlike school, where interaction is confined to about 30 students of the same age. There is also time to connect with nature.
Without the pressure to fit everyone into one discipline, creative ideas can be thought through, reflected upon, and then put into practice.
3. It protects you from exam culture
Most of us remember very little of what we learned for exams. The goal was never to learn; it was to score. Schools convince some students, like me, to keep running that race. They also push low achievers into a false grade consciousness, making them believe their Cs and Ds reflect their own lack of potential rather than flaws in the system.
By not testing you every other month, homeschooling leaves room for rich thoughts and ideas and lets you enjoy the intrinsic beauty of learning. You study to understand the deeper realities of life, not to collect an A.
4. It celebrates differences between minds
My biggest objection to schools and colleges is that they fail to celebrate the differences between human minds. Children are not all the same, and it is not normal to expect them to be. In school, everyone is expected to study the same way, with the same teachers, books, notes, and syllabi. This one-size-fits-all approach restricts children from exploring different channels of knowledge.
I was shocked to realize that my O level history book did not give a complete account of Pakistan’s past. It left out many important figures and underrepresented great personalities like Allama Iqbal, who was shown as little more than the man who gave a speech at Allahabad. But at that time, we were not allowed to question. After memorizing a one-sided version of history, I now doubt much of what we studied in school.
Homeschooling gives you the space to explore, integrate, experiment, test, and verify whatever you learn, which in my experience makes it a more dependable way to learn.
5. It builds confidence in learning
Homeschoolers take charge of their own education. They learn which study techniques suit them and plan their schedules accordingly. They also cover books and syllabi in much less time than a school year, which lets them read more and widen their knowledge.
Homeschooling is a more natural option anyway, and I am glad I chose it.
Homeschooling FAQs: Common Questions Answered
How do children study without teachers?
Allah has placed immense potential in every soul, so studying through resources alone is entirely possible. I do not mean to undermine the student-teacher relationship, though. Students can hire a teacher or attend tuitions for a reasonable period when they need help.
How do homeschoolers enroll for qualifications?
There is no barrier to accessing qualifications. Exam boards accept private candidates, and for O and A levels, much of the process can be managed online.
How do homeschooled children know what to study?
Choose books recommended by scholarly and reliable people. Research on specific topics and reading about authors also helps. For a particular qualification, recommended books and resources are listed on the board’s website, so all you have to do is search.
Is homeschooling expensive?
Generally, no. It saves much of the cost of school fees, transport, uniforms, and extracurricular activities.
What do homeschooled kids do with all the extra time?
Plenty. Join skill programs, learn languages, read more, play sports, spend time with family, have reflective conversations, pick up new hobbies, and ponder. The world has far more to offer your children than a school that does little.
Who conducts routine tests?
In my view, frequent tests do not show what children are capable of, so they are not essential. Let children learn without the pressure of unneeded assessments, and do not let exams contaminate the beauty of learning. Parents who want to track progress can use informal check-ins instead.
Does every homeschooled child need a tight schedule?
It varies. Some children want one and some do not. Let them decide which time of day suits them best for study.
What if children do not sit down to study at all?
Maintain a learning environment. Build small libraries and study spaces. Above all, adults need to study too, because no one is exempt from acquiring knowledge. Children are likely to read when they see their parents doing the same.
Final Thoughts: Is Homeschooling Worth It?
Some people argue that schools do manage to impart some knowledge, if not more.
But at what cost? If it comes at the cost of my confidence, character, and creativity, I am sorry. It is a bad trade.
May Allah bestow upon us knowledge that nourishes us in this life and the hereafter. Ameen.
Related reading:


0 Comments