5 Popular Parenting Tips You Should NOT Follow

Abdul Basit Sangani

Why I No Longer Follow These “Popular” Parenting Tips
— A Young Parent’s Reflection on What Really Matters

Ever since I became a father, I’ve been haunted by a sense of responsibility far greater than I imagined. It’s not just about feeding, clothing, or educating my son—it’s about raising him with dignity, balance, and values rooted in our Islamic worldview. That means I constantly find myself questioning the assumptions modern parenting often runs on.

Recently, I came across a powerful critique of five commonly celebrated parenting tips. The more I reflected on them, the more I realized how deeply they clash with the kind of human being I want my child to become. These ideas aren’t just ineffective—they subtly chip away at our children’s character and our ability to parent with wisdom.

Let me walk you through them, one by one.


1. “Never say no to your child.”

This advice sounds loving on the surface but is dangerously unrealistic. If we never say no, how will our child learn boundaries? Limits are not restrictions—they are the framework that help us recognize right from wrong.

But I also learned that saying no shouldn’t be harsh or dismissive. It should come with empathy and care. It’s not about power; it’s about love with responsibility. When we protect our child’s self-respect while still offering necessary guidance, we do far more for their future than giving in to every request.


2. “Praise your child often.”

I’ve struggled with this one. Praise feels natural. A proud smile, a compliment—it’s what we do when we love someone, right?

But there’s a deeper issue here. Constant praise, especially for things that require no real effort or sacrifice, becomes addictive. Children may begin to seek approval instead of meaning. It trains them to perform rather than to grow.

True growth happens when a child learns to appreciate their own effort, not when they’re waiting for applause. We must show them that doing good is enough, even if no one notices.


3. “Use rewards and punishments to control behavior.”

I’ve seen how this plays out even among well-meaning parents. “Finish your food and I’ll give you chocolate.” “Get good grades or no screen time.”

But what happens when the reward disappears? Does the behavior vanish too?

The goal shouldn’t be compliance but character. A child should help others because it’s right, not because they’ll get a prize. Occasionally rewarding a child out of affection is fine. But shaping their moral compass around carrots and sticks? That’s not the kind of human being I want to raise.


4. “Compare your child to others.”

Comparison is one of the quickest ways to destroy peace in the home. Whether it’s a cousin, a classmate, or even our own childhood selves—placing children side-by-side in a race they never signed up for does more harm than good.

Every child is unique. Every soul has its own path and timing. When we compare, we’re essentially saying: “You are not enough.” That’s a message no child deserves to hear.


5. “Set external, time-bound goals for your child.”

Here’s where many of us get trapped. We believe children must achieve XYZ by age X. Quran memorization in 3 years. Reading fluency by 6. Public speaking by 8.

But whose timeline is this? Who set the standard?

I was reminded that even the Prophet ï·ș received revelation over 23 years. Why, then, do we pressure a 9-year-old to meet milestones that adults struggle with?

True learning is owned, not imposed. The targets that matter are those that emerge from within the child—with gentle encouragement from us, yes—but never forced deadlines.


What I’m Trying to Embrace Instead

I don’t claim to have all the answers. I’m just starting out on this parenting journey. But I do know this:

  • My job isn’t to mold my son into an image society approves of.

  • It’s to preserve his innate goodness, nurture his spirit, and guide him toward a life of meaning.

  • That requires patience. Trust. And a conscious rejection of practices that promise short-term obedience at the cost of long-term harm.

Parenting isn’t about perfect techniques. It’s about being present, principled, and honest. It’s about walking alongside your child as they learn—not dragging them down a path they didn’t choose.

And if you’ve made mistakes (as I’m sure I will), remember: what matters is what you choose next.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *